The Lagos State Government has asked the Court of Appeal in Lagos to restore its power to register and license cinemas.
It filed an appeal challenging a March 18, 2020 Federal High Court judgment which held that only the Federal Government can exercise such power.
The state also filed a stay of execution of the judgment.
The lower court decision was delivered by Justice Chuka Obiozor, a Professor of Law, in Suit No. FHC/L/CS/1502/2016, Harris & Annis Limited v Attorney-General of Lagos State & 3 Ors.
The judge held that the Lagos State Government cannot exercise regulatory powers to register and license cinema exhibition centres under the Cinematograph Law of Lagos State, because a Federal Law already covers such activity.
But Director, Public Affairs of the Lagos State Ministry of Justice (MOJ), Mr Kayode Oyekanmi, told The Nation yesterday that the state had challenged the decision.
“We have, however, filed a notice of appeal and stay of application,” Oyekanmi said.
At the lower court, the plaintiff, Harris & Annis Limited, who operates ‘Dew Cinema’ in Lagos, joined the Attorney-General of Lagos State, the Lagos State Film and Video Censors Board (LSFVCB), the Attorney-General of the Federation, and the National Film and Video Censors Board (NFVCB) as defendants.
The plaintiff’s counsel, Chijioke Emeka, argued that the NFVCB Act 1993 and the Cinematograph Law of Lagos State 2004 having given the NFVCB and the LSFVCB powers to register and license premises for film and video exhibition, the plaintiff is brought under the registration and licensing regulation of both bodies under sections 17, 21 and 25(2) of the Federal Law and sections 23 and 24 of the State Law, a scenario unintended by the constitution.
The plaintiff further argued that because it was registered and licensed by the NFVCB and paid its annual licensing fees to the Federal Government; the LSFVCB cannot demand the same registration and annual licensing fee from it.
Counsel for the Attorney-General of Lagos State and the LSFVCB, A. O. Idowu, contended that the constitution allows both the Federal and Lagos State governments to have concurrent power to make laws which can operate side by side with each other.
Ruling, Justice Obiozor held that Item 16, Part II of the Second Schedule in the 1999 Constitution gives concurrent powers to both the Federal and State legislatures to make law creating a body to register cinema premises and collect annual license fees.
However, since the National Assembly has made a law which covered the field, the law made by the Lagos House of Assembly on the same issue “remains otiose and inoperative.
“Item 16(b) however allows the State Law to censor films and videos to be exhibited in Lagos State.”
It was held that since both laws exact registration and licensing fees, the state law is not binding.
“I have examined sections 17, 21 and 25(2) of the National Film and Video Censors Board Act and sections 23 and 24 of the Cinematograph Law Cap. C8, Laws of Lagos State and find a case of co-existence of a Federal Law and a State Law on the subject matter of registration and licensing of premises for film and video exhibition.
“To that extent therefore, the Federal Law prevails and the law of State must go into abeyance while the Federal law subsists,” the Judge said.
The Court also held that a ‘Memorandum of Understanding’, ‘Exhibit LASG 1’, entered into between the NFVCB and the LSFVCB under which both bodies cooperate to exact dual registration and licensing fees from cinema operators, is “non sequitur”.
This, the judge explained, is because the agreement hinges on a state law which is “inoperative”.
Just want to say what a great blog you got here!I’ve been around for quite a lot of time, but finally decided to show my appreciation of your work!
It’s clear that you are passionate about making a positive impact and your blog is a testament to that Thank you for all that you do
You have a way of making each of your readers feel seen and heard That’s a special quality that not all bloggers possess Thank you for creating a safe space for us
This is such an important reminder and one that I needed to hear today Thank you for always providing timely and relevant content
Your blog stands out in a sea of generic and formulaic content Your unique voice and perspective are what keep me coming back for more
Give a round of applause in the comments to show your appreciation!
I love how you incorporate personal stories and experiences into your posts It makes your content relatable and authentic
Your posts are so well-written and eloquent It’s impossible not to be moved by your words Keep using your voice to spread positivity
This blog is such a hidden gem I stumbled upon it by chance and now I’m completely hooked!
Your blog has helped me through some tough times and I am so grateful for your wise words and positive outlook
Your blog post had me hooked from the first sentence.
This blog post is worth the read – trust us!
From the insightful commentary to the captivating writing, every word of this post is top-notch. Kudos to the author for producing such fantastic content.
Your blog is like a breath of fresh air in a sea of negativity and pessimism Thank you for being a source of light and hope
This blog has become a part of my daily routine I start my mornings with a cup of coffee and your latest post
Your writing is so eloquent and heartfelt It’s impossible not to be moved by your words Thank you for sharing your gift with the world
Give a round of applause in the comments to show your appreciation!
It’s clear that you are passionate about making a positive impact and your blog is a testament to that Thank you for all that you do
Your posts always leave me feeling motivated and empowered You have a gift for inspiring others and it’s evident in your writing
Your blog post had me hooked from the first sentence.
Your writing has a way of making complicated topics easier to understand It’s evident how much research and effort goes into each post
Your writing is so engaging and easy to read It makes it a pleasure to visit your blog and learn from your insights and experiences
This blog is such a hidden gem I stumbled upon it by chance and now I’m completely hooked!
Your writing is so relatable and down-to-earth It’s like chatting with a good friend over a cup of coffee Keep sharing your wisdom with us
This blog post hit all the right notes!
Drop a link to your favorite blog post of yours in the comments below, I’d love to read more.
I know this is not exactly on topic, but i have a blog using the blogengine platform as well and i’m having issues with my comments displaying. is there a setting i am forgetting? maybe you could help me out? thank you.
My issues have been very similar, with my family. But, we made some different decisions. It’s complex.
You ma’am have a way with words. Thank you very much!
Great write-up, I am a big believer in placing comments on sites to inform the blog writers know that they’ve added something advantageous to the world wide web!
Your content always manages to captivate and educate me. Keep up the fantastic work!
This blog is not just about the content, but also the community it fosters I’ve connected with so many like-minded individuals here
Your writing is so relatable and down-to-earth It’s like having a conversation with a good friend Thank you for always being real with your readers
Wow, this blogger is seriously impressive!
Your positivity and optimism are contagious It’s evident that you genuinely care about your readers and their well-being
It’s clear that you truly care about your readers and want to make a positive impact on their lives Thank you for all that you do
Love this appreciation for great content
Your writing style is so engaging and easy to follow I find myself reading through each post without even realizing I’ve reached the end
Looking forward to your next post. Keep up the good work!
Thank you for sharing your personal experiences and stories It takes courage to open up and you do it with such grace and authenticity
Let us know in the comments which of their posts has resonated with you the most.
This blog is a great resource for anyone looking to live a more mindful and intentional life Thank you for providing valuable advice and tips
I appreciate how well-researched and detailed your posts are It’s evident that you put a lot of time and effort into providing valuable information to your readers
Your writing is a breath of fresh air It’s clear that you put a lot of thought and effort into each and every post
I have been struggling with this issue for a while and your post has provided me with much-needed guidance and clarity Thank you so much
Your blog is like a breath of fresh air in a sea of negativity and pessimism Thank you for being a source of light and hope
From start to finish, your content is simply amazing. You have a talent for making complex topics easy to understand and I always come away with valuable insights.
There most be a solution for this problem, some people think there will be now solutions, but i think there wil be one.
Nice blog here! Also your web site loads up very fast! What host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my web site loaded up as fast as yours lol
Simply wish to say the frankness in your article is surprising.
Glad to be one of many visitants on this amazing site : D.
Do you offer workshops?
Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I’ve really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing in your feed and I am hoping you write again very soon!
I Am Going To have to come back again when my course load lets up – however I am taking your Rss feed so i can go through your site offline. Thanks.
Thanks for posting this. Looking for these resources 😀
Every time I read one of your posts, I come away with something new and interesting to think about. Thanks for consistently putting out such great content!
Your writing is so relatable and down-to-earth It’s like having a conversation with a good friend Thank you for always being real with your readers
This is exactly what I needed to read today Your words have provided me with much-needed reassurance and comfort
I’ve been following this blog for years and it’s amazing to see how much it has grown and evolved Congratulations on all your success!
I want to express my appreciation for the writer of this blog post. It’s clear they put a lot of effort and thought into their work, and it shows. From the informative content to the engaging writing style, I thoroughly enjoyed reading it.
Your blog stands out in a sea of generic and formulaic content Your unique voice and perspective are what keep me coming back for more
I couldn’t stop scrolling and reading, your content is truly one-of-a-kind. Thank you for all the time and effort you put into creating such amazing content.
This post hits close to home for me and I am grateful for your insight and understanding on this topic Keep doing what you do
Your blog post had me hooked from the first sentence.
Your blog has helped me through some tough times and I am so grateful for your wise words and positive outlook
I love how this blog gives a voice to important social and political issues It’s important to use your platform for good, and you do that flawlessly
I just wanted to take a moment to say how much I appreciate your blog posts. They’re always well-written, informative, and keep me coming back for more. Keep up the great work!
The positivity and optimism conveyed in this blog never fails to uplift my spirits Thank you for spreading joy and positivity in the world
This is exactly what I needed to read today Your words have given me a new perspective and renewed hope Thank you
Your writing is so powerful and has the ability to make a real difference in people’s lives Keep using your voice to spread kindness and positivity
I truly admire how you tackle difficult topics and address them in a respectful and thought-provoking manner